January transfer window provides attacking options

Trabzonspor's 3-0 Champions League Group B defeat to CSKA Moscow, 18th October 2011

January has been an eventful month for the two main football clubs of Glasgow – in vastly different ways. Aside from crashing out of the Scottish Cup to Dundee Utd, Rangers lurch ominously from one off-field bombshell to the next (as detailed by the superb Phil Mac Giolla Bhain  and RTC) Neil Lennon meanwhile has been quietly grappling with the transfer window. Patiently stroking transfer target after transfer target off the list, the constraints of competing in the international market is painfully clear.

This window especially, sees player values exaggerated, partly due to supply – who wants to lose anybody midway through the season? And so for a sensible purchaser – that is, a club operating within it’s capabilities – it’s the bargain basement loans and free signings where the greatest value is to be found.

Hot prospects Rabiu Ibrahim and Mikael Lustig were snapped up for free, and are fine examples of Lennon and Peter Lawwell’s long-term ‘moneyball’ style transfer policy. Cheap, young and work in progress – buy low sell high. The loan acquisition of 28-year-old Paweł Brożek also fits the policy, albeit in a different manner. The value here, is in landing an experienced player without risk – Lawwell has managed to negotiate into the terms of the half-season loan, a future fee.

Paweł Brożek – brief scout report

In the relative comfort of the Polish Ekstraklasa, Paweł finished top scorer in seasons 2008-09 and 2009-10 playing for Wisla Krakow. His goalscoring form earned Brozek, along with his twin brother (a left-back), a move to Turkish Süper Lig giants Trabzonspor for an undisclosed fee.

In Brozek’s first full season, by the time of facing CSKA Moscow in the Champions League group stage, he had only managed 3 league starts and 1 goal – overwhelmingly due to the form of Burak Yilmaz, who has yielded an astonishing 25 goals in 22 matches.

Unfortunately, Halil Altintop and Paulo Henrique had been established as the next forwards in the pecking order. With the Champions League considered second fiddle to the Turkish Süper Lig (Trabzonspor were only involved due to Fenerbache’s match fixing scandal) Brozek was given a rare chance to stake a claim in the side.

With Yilmaz suspended, Brozek came on at half-time for off-form winger Alanzinho with CSKA already a goal ahead.

Playing style

The substitution saw starting striker Altintop move wider left, reminiscent of Georgios Samaras’ favoured position for Celtic. Brozek took on the responsibility of focal point of the attack.

It’s well documented that Neil Lennon has been after another physical presence up top to provide competition and a ‘plan B’. But his new manager appreciates that Brozek is not that sought after target-man. “Pawel is a bit like Gary Hooper” Lennon said. “sharp with good feet, 5ft 10in and he knows where the goal is. He’s a bit like Maciej Zurawski was when he first came.”

Identifying a new targetman will have to wait, but the addition of Brozek will provide much needed proven backup to Hooper and Anthony Stokes. Cynics will doubt the need for a fourth striker (fifth if you include the injured Mo Bangura – out for the season), but it’s a well-known adage that to challenge on three or more fronts, four top class strikers is a minimum requirement.

The Luzhniki defence proved to be frustrating adversaries for Brozek, who toiled in – as new team-mates Stokes and Hooper refer to it – the graveyard shift, or the lone striker role. The service just wasn’t provided. While the right-back Ondrej Celustka was getting forward and overlapping well and the main playmaker Adrian Mierzejewski posed a tricky threat, no service was forthcoming for the isolated Brozek.

The hosts sat back, hitting aggressively on the counter, leaving no space in behind for darting runs on goal. Brozek’s preference instead, was to drop off the defenders, between the lines attempting to link-up play. The move allowed space to receive an initial pass, and then, after off-loading the ball purposefully, an opportunity for a running start on the opposition centre-backs.

An accurate return pass, however never came, making for an unrewarding evening. Trabzonspor suffered a real smash and grab, with the pace of Seydou Doumbia and Vagner Love on the counter ultimately the deciding factor. Altintop late-on, was moved back up front after spending much of the second half out wide. An attempt to take the load off Brozek to an extent, but it was too little too late.

Despite the result, sufficient information could be gleaned on Celtic’s new recruit. Quite simply direct, experienced backup to Hooper and Stokes, as Lennon warns “if one of them gets injured or suspended, we could be a goalscorer short — and Pawel is a goalscorer.” At only 5’10” he won’t be considered a targetman. But, his upper-body strength and ability in the air is an improvement on those two. He therefore might be seen as a more ‘complementary’ partner for one or the other.

Lennon cites the European Championships inPolandas an additional motivation, but unfortunately for Brozek his chance of impressing for his temporary new employer isn’t in his hands.


About tictacticuk

Football fan and commentator of all things Celtic FC.
This entry was posted in Player Profile, scout report and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to January transfer window provides attacking options

  1. Jelly and Ice-cream says:

    Great article, as always. Are there any plans to do one on Ibrahim? He seems like a really interesting buy in my opinion due to his natural role being the No. 10 position. Do you think Neil Lennon intends to regularly implement him, changing the usual formation from the lopsided 4-4-2 to a 4-5-1 to accommodate Rabiu, or will he either be played out of position up front or on the wing? I personally think he’ll be reserved for tough away fixture (maybe even Tynecastle on Wednesday!) or European games. Whatever the case, it’s good to know we have the option as forrest, commons, mccourt etc. aren’t at their best when played in that No. 10 role; as you yourself have extensively covered. Hope we’ve uncovered another midfield gem anyway.

    • tictacticuk says:

      Hi cheers for reading.

      I’ve submitted a piece on Ibrahim to CQ Magazine for it’s next issue http://www.celticquicknews.co.uk/

      I’m not sure when it will be made available, but should be quite soon.

      Don’t want to go into it too much here with that in mind, but I do agree with some of the things you’ve pointed out. He’ll be useful when either a 4-2-3-1 is required or a more technical brand of football (as opposed to a clogging snowy February night), so I’m thinking Europe next season. Lennon’s been chasing a natural version of this system for a while.

      Not as likely (but still not a bad shout) is being shunted out wide, kind of like Commons now or Naka once was.

      Thanks again for writing though, and I hope I can answer some of those questions for CQN. Might post a link on the blog when it’s released.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s